Great Powers and Borderlines — Lines Drawn on a Map
Who drew the borders of the Middle East, and under what circumstances?
In the 19th century, Europe's great powers kept a close eye on the weakening Ottoman Empire. In 1869, the Suez Canal opened in Egypt. The Mediterranean and the Indian Ocean were directly connected, and for Britain, protecting the route to India became a national priority. The Middle East had become a global "passageway."
When World War I began in 1914, the Ottoman Empire entered on Germany's side. Britain tried to weaken the Ottomans from within, making a promise to the Arab leader Hussein to the effect that if he cooperated in the war, they would support Arab independence (the Hussein–McMahon Correspondence, 1915–16).
Around the same time, however, Britain and France had concluded a secret agreement to divide the Middle East into their respective spheres of influence after the war (the Sykes–Picot Agreement, 1916). Furthermore, in 1917, Britain issued a declaration (the Balfour Declaration) supporting the establishment of a "national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine.
These promises were difficult to reconcile with one another. For this reason, this later came to be called "three-tongued (triple-dealing) diplomacy." After the war ended, at the San Remo Conference of 1920 and other meetings, it was decided that France would administer Syria and Lebanon, and Britain would administer Iraq and Palestine (with Transjordan later separated) as mandates.
Meanwhile, after World War I, Turkey defeated the Allied powers in its War of Independence and secured its current borders with the Treaty of Lausanne in 1923. On the Arabian Peninsula, Ibn Saud united the tribes and founded the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in 1932. Iraq achieved formal independence in 1932. Many of today's countries took shape during this era.
However, some argue that it is too simplistic to think that all of today's problems in the Middle East are the fault of that one agreement. The borders were not drawn exactly as stipulated, and the later politics of the countries and the choices of their peoples also moved history. Still, it is certain that the lines on the map have long affected people's lives.
Mini timeline
- 1869Suez Canal opens
- 1914World War I begins; Ottoman Empire enters the war
- 1916Sykes–Picot Agreement (secret Anglo-French agreement)
- 1917Balfour Declaration
- 1923Foundation of the Republic of Turkey; Treaty of Lausanne
People in this chapter
He built a new country through bold reforms, including the separation of religion and state.
He united most of the Arabian Peninsula and founded the kingdom in 1932.
Meanwhile, elsewhere
Connection to Japan
Japan's victory in the Russo-Japanese War is said to have given a major stimulus to intellectuals across Asia, including the Middle East.
Why it still matters
Parts of the borders of Syria, Iraq, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia are drawn as straight lines on the map. From today's map, one can see the history of artificial lines drawn across the desert through the 1920s in negotiations between the great powers and local leaders (not all straight borders were drawn by the Sykes–Picot Agreement).
Perspectives differ
- Assessment of the "three-tongued diplomacy"
- The common view is that the promises contradicted each other, but scholars debate the exact content of the promises and the degree of contradiction.
- The Sykes–Picot Agreement and today's borders
- Today's borders are not exactly those of the agreement; they changed through subsequent negotiations and wars. Some point out that viewing the agreement as the sole cause of current chaos is an oversimplification.
- The Armenian tragedy (1915)
- During World War I, many Armenians died in forced deportations and killings within the Ottoman Empire. The large number of casualties is widely acknowledged, but many historians, and the parliaments and governments of a number of countries, describe it as "genocide," while the Turkish government rejects the term, saying the deaths resulted from wartime deportations and not from a planned mass killing. Governments respond differently.
Facts checked (5, verified by AI on the web)
- Confirmed 1869: Suez Canal opens Suez Canal (Britannica)
Formally opened on November 17, 1869. - Confirmed 1915–16: Hussein–McMahon Correspondence promises support for Arab independence Husayn-McMahon correspondence (Britannica)
Generally read as a promise of independence, but the scope is debated. - Confirmed 1916: Sykes–Picot Agreement (secret Anglo-French agreement) Sykes-Picot Agreement (Britannica)
Agreed in early 1916, ratified in May; made public in 1917. - Confirmed 1917: Balfour Declaration Balfour Declaration (Britannica)
Dated November 2, 1917, as a letter from Foreign Secretary Balfour to Lord Rothschild. - Confirmed 1923: Treaty of Lausanne; 1932: Kingdom of Saudi Arabia EBSCO Research Starters: Turkish War of Independence
Treaty of Lausanne signed in July 1923 (dates vary between 23rd and 24th). The renaming to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in 1932 is recorded by the U.S. State Department's Office of the Historian as a royal decree of September 18, 1932.
Sources
Britannica: Sykes-Picot Agreement
Britannica: Balfour Declaration
Britannica: Husayn-McMahon correspondence
Britannica: Suez Canal
EBSCO Research Starters: Turkish War of Independence
Office of the Historian: Saudi Arabia
* AI-drafted and cross-checked; human review is in progress. Status: