Women Who Moved History — From Wu Zetian to Catherine the Great
Why are women who ruled countries often spoken of as 'wicked women' or 'exceptions'?
Hatshepsut of ancient Egypt held the throne around the 15th century BC (said to be about 1479–1458 BC). She was initially regent for her stepson Thutmose III, but later proclaimed herself king. Eventually, she was also depicted in statues with the attire and physique of a male king. It is also known that her name was removed from monuments after her death. However, whether the motive was her perceived disruption of order or some other reason remains uncertain to this day.
Wu Zetian (Empress Wu) of the Tang dynasty strengthened her power further after the death of her husband Emperor Gaozong in 683, and in 690 proclaimed herself emperor, changing the dynasty name to 'Zhou'. Her reign lasted until 705. She is said to have collected people's petitions in small boxes and promoted people regardless of family background. On the other hand, later historians, disliking a woman ruling like a man, are said to have portrayed her as a cold-hearted villainess.
In the region of southwestern Africa, in what is now Angola, Nzinga (Zinga) was active in the 17th century. Following her brother's death in the 1620s, she is said to have taken the throne of Ndongo. While alternately allying with and fighting the Portuguese and partnering with the Dutch, she later conquered the kingdom of Matamba to make it her new base, and died in 1663. It is said that women succeeded her as rulers as well. Many European records described her as 'cunning'.
Elizabeth I of England ruled the country for about 45 years (over 44 years), from 1558 to 1603. She is said to have been attentive to her public image, crafting her appearance as queen through attire, jewelry, and portraits. The 'Armada Portrait' of about 1588 depicts the defeat of the Spanish Armada in the background. This era was later called the 'Elizabethan era'. The fact that she ruled the country for a long time without marrying has also been discussed in various ways.
Catherine the Great of Russia was born in a small German principality, came to the throne via a coup in 1762 (June in the Julian calendar) that deposed her husband Peter III, and ruled until her death in 1796. She is known for local administrative reforms, introducing a school system, founding the Hermitage Museum, and annexing Crimea. At the same time, she further strengthened and expanded serfdom. She is also famous for her close friendship with Voltaire and Diderot. While her reign is considered outstanding, many rumors about her also survive.
Empress Dowager Cixi of the Qing dynasty long held real power, from 1861 until her death in 1908, as mother or aunt to the emperors. For a long time, she was described as 'cold-hearted and backward', but in recent years, a reassessment is also underway. The images of the women discussed so far have all been shaped by the standpoint of the writers. When male historians viewed female rule as an anomaly, how did they depict such rulers? That is the question of this chapter.
Mini timeline
- c. 15th century BCHatshepsut ascends the throne as king
- 690Wu Zetian changes the dynasty name to 'Zhou' and becomes emperor
- 1558–1603Elizabeth I rules England
- 17th century (1620s–1663)Nzinga rules Ndongo, later Matamba
- 1762–1796Catherine the Great rules Russia
- 1861–1908Empress Dowager Cixi holds power in the Qing dynasty
People in this chapter
Known as the only female emperor in Chinese history. The negative reputation shaped by later historians is said to still influence the tone of narratives about her.
Known for her diplomacy and warfare with the Portuguese and Dutch, and appears frequently in European records.
Corresponded with Enlightenment thinkers and promoted reforms, while simultaneously strengthening serfdom.
Meanwhile, elsewhere
Connection to Japan
The year 690, when Wu Zetian ascended the throne, is said to correspond to the year Empress Jitō ascended the throne in Japan, near the end of the Asuka period. Around this time, Japan had several female emperors, beginning with Empress Suiko (late 6th to early 7th century). The year 1796, when Catherine the Great died, corresponds to the 8th year of the Kansei era.
Why it still matters
Efforts to reexamine female rulers not as special 'exceptions,' but as individual rulers in their own right, are spreading in scholarship worldwide. Hatshepsut's mortuary temple (Egypt) is still visited by many, and the name of the Hermitage Museum, whose collection was started by Catherine the Great, is known around the world.
Perspectives differ
- Who created the 'villainess' image?
- Wu Zetian is said to have been portrayed as a cold-hearted usurper by later male historians. Some studies point out that the story of her killing her own daughter cannot be verified. On the other hand, some perspectives point to advances in politics and agriculture during her era. This book does not decide which is the 'true image'; please use these accounts as material for considering the standpoint of the historical sources' authors as well.
- Why was Hatshepsut's name erased?
- The explanation that her name was erased from monuments after her death because a female king was seen as disrupting order is considered the most prevalent. Although the erasure is said to have been carried out near the end of Thutmose III's reign, the exact motive is still debated, including why it happened some 20 years after her death. There is also a view that her depiction in male form was meant not to hide her gender, but to signify the office of the king.
- Nzinga and European records
- Most detailed records of Nzinga are by European writers, such as the Portuguese. Terms like 'cunning' are thought to be evaluations from the perspective of adversaries. Although the majority of records are by Europeans, some of her own letters survive, requiring careful comparison when interpreting motivations.
- How to evaluate Empress Dowager Cixi
- Cixi was long described as 'cold-hearted and conservative,' and it is also pointed out that this image was created after the fall of the Qing dynasty. In recent years, there has been a reassessment based on new materials, such as Jung Chang's biography. However, that biography is also criticized for being too biased toward praise, and the evaluation remains unsettled. Some studies also point out that Western books about her mix fact and fiction.
- The 'rumors' about Catherine the Great
- There is said to be no solid evidence regarding her involvement in her husband's death. Stories about the paternity of her children are also said to be mostly speculative. The more famous the anecdote, the more likely it is to include elements added later.
Facts checked (11, verified by AI on the web)
- Confirmed Hatshepsut was on the throne around 1479–1458 BC, went from regent to king. Depicted as a male king. Name erased after death. World History Encyclopedia: Hatshepsut(事典)
Confirmed in the encyclopedia text. The erasure being by Thutmose III is a prevalent view, but not definitive. The explanation of motives (seen as disrupting order, etc.) is on the same page. Depiction with male king's attire and physique is confirmed on the same page. - Corrected & confirmed Wu Zetian changed the dynasty name to 'Zhou' and became emperor in 690, reign until about 705. World History Encyclopedia: Wu Zetian(事典)
The enthronement and name change in 690 are confirmed in the encyclopedia. The end of the reign differs between the heading of the same page (704) and the text (705), so a range of 'about 705' was used. - Confirmed Wu Zetian is said to have collected petitions in small boxes and promoted people regardless of family background. Later historians disliked female rule and portrayed her as a cold-hearted villainess. The story of killing her daughter cannot be verified. World History Encyclopedia: Wu Zetian(事典)
Confirmed in the encyclopedia text. Regarding the petition box, a researcher's view that it was primarily for information gathering is also on the same page. - Confirmed Nzinga took the throne in the 1620s, allied and conflicted with Portugal, allied with the Dutch in the 1640s, created a new kingdom in Matamba, died around 1663, and was succeeded by women. Encyclopedia.com (Encyclopedia of World History / Women in World History): Njinga (c. 1580s-1663)(事典)
Confirmed in the text (accession in 1624, to Matamba in 1629, Dutch capture of Luanda in 1641, treaty with Portugal in 1656, death in 1663). Due to discrepancies in dates within the same page, the text uses ranges. - Confirmed European records described Nzinga as 'cunning'. Encyclopedia.com (Encyclopedia of World History / Women in World History): Njinga (c. 1580s-1663)(事典)
Confirmed on the same page with an example of a European (Captain Fuller) calling her a 'cunning and prudent Virago'. The point that most records are from the European side is not directly discussed on that page. - Confirmed Elizabeth I reigned 1558–1603, was attentive to her appearance. The 'Armada Portrait' of about 1588 depicts the defeat of the Armada in the background. World History Encyclopedia: Elizabeth I(事典)
Confirmed in the encyclopedia text (the caption gives a reign notation of 1588–1603, but the text gives 1558). The fact that she did not marry is not confirmed on that page and is not discussed in detail in the text. - Confirmed Catherine the Great ascended via a coup in June 1762 and died in 1796. Reforms in administration and education, founding of the Hermitage, annexation of Crimea. Conservative on serfdom. No solid evidence of involvement in her husband's death. Praised by Voltaire and Diderot. World History Encyclopedia: Catherine the Great(事典)
Confirmed in the encyclopedia text (coup on June 28, 1762; coronation on September 22. Paternity of children remains speculative). 'Born in a small principality' is from the description of her being from Anhalt-Zerbst. - Confirmed Empress Dowager Cixi held power from 1861–1908, long described as 'cold-hearted and backward'; this image is said to have been created by nationalists after the fall of the Qing dynasty. Recent biographies prompt reassessment, but those biographies are also criticized for bias. ICSIN: Book Review: Redefining Empress Dowager Cixi(書評)
Confirmed in the book review text. Birth and death years are not on that page; the text does not give her death year (1908 is given as the end of her period of rule). Since it is a book review, not a primary source or specialized monograph, strong assertions were avoided. - Confirmed Western books about Cixi mix fact and fiction. University of Victoria (DSpace): The Western Perception of Empress Dowager Cixi(学位論文)
Confirmed in a thesis abstract. Only the abstract was confirmed, not the full thesis. It is a student paper and is not treated as a definitive evaluation. - Unverified The accession of Empress Jitō in Japan was in 690, Empress Suiko was a female emperor in the early 7th century, and 1796 was the 8th year of Kansei. World History Encyclopedia: Wu Zetian(事典)
WHE Empress Jitō page returns 403; no other source text verified. - Unverified Contemporary events in other regions (Mitanni/Hittites, Umayyad Caliphate, Age of Enlightenment). World History Encyclopedia: Catherine the Great(事典)
No source texts read; unverified.
Sources
World History Encyclopedia: Hatshepsut(事典)
World History Encyclopedia: Wu Zetian(事典)
World History Encyclopedia: Elizabeth I(事典)
World History Encyclopedia: Catherine the Great(事典)
Encyclopedia.com (Encyclopedia of World History / Women in World History): Njinga (c. 1580s-1663)(事典)
ICSIN: Book Review: Redefining Empress Dowager Cixi(書評)
University of Victoria (DSpace): The Western Perception of Empress Dowager Cixi(学位論文)
* AI-drafted and cross-checked; human review is in progress. Status: